The Changing Investor Landscape Under COVID-19
Private equity firms face different competition for coveted assets
INSIGHT ARTICLE |
"We always used to talk with PE firms about recession-proof business. Now we're talking about pandemic-proof businesses." -Ben Gibbons, RSM Canada's Private Equity Leader
A common sentiment in today’s market is that COVID-19 will have an impact on what types of investors will be active over the next few years. Many industry experts expect private equity (PE) sponsors to be especially active. However, as the PE industry has grown over the decades, competition from other investor types has increased. Alternative buyers such as family offices and Canadian pension plans are now established players in the market, while sovereign wealth funds have become permanent equity providers to buyouts as well. Traditional leveraged buyout firms also face stiff competition from specialized PE firms, distressed investors, first-time funds and an array of other niche investors that have carved out their own pockets in the market.
While traditional PE firms cater to limited partners (LPs) and have fixed investment timelines, other investor types enjoy a permanent capital structure. For these players, time isn’t necessarily of the essence. While 2021 may turn into a feeding frenzy for PE, longer- term investors can remain as selective as they’ve always been. Corporate acquirers, meanwhile, won’t simply buy market share because acquisition targets have lower valuations, but they will align their mergers and acquisitions (M&A) strategy on both the buy side and sell side with their long-term business plan, particularly as business models evolve. “Strategic acquirer” will take on a more literal meaning in 2021, as we’ll see specific and significant synergies and accretion opportunities driving corporate M&A. Traditional PE firms will face different competition over the near term for highly coveted assets.
Set to surge?
PE deal activity came to a virtual halt last summer amid pandemic anxiety, according to PitchBook Data. As expected, though, it started to perk up later in the year and has carried momentum forward into 2021. Aggregate deal value was higher in both October and December 2020 than in January 2020, before COVID-19 became a market factor. Deal count, however, has not recovered to pre-pandemic levels, which means deal sizes have risen significantly. The median PE deal size in 2020 was $440 million compared to $100 million in 2019, according to PitchBook Data.
2021 coming into focus
In the United States alone, PE firms had about $721 billion of unspent capital as of June 30, 2020, and because of the slowdown in 2020 deal activity, much of that capital is now behind schedule. PE firms are anxious to put it to use as valuations have stabilized and uncertainty continues to diminish. There are reasons to believe valuations will increase in 2021 as competition for assets heats up. Accompanying buy-side momentum will be a wave of delayed PE exits coming to market that are healthy enough to justify higher valuations, while those that don’t meet this threshold will remain on the sidelines. Distressed opportunities will be visible, however. With the potential for further government funding programs to wane over 2021, alternative sources of capital will come in the form of special situations groups. If vaccines can’t be distributed as efficiently as planned, PE may gain a stronghold in deal flow over the next six months.
We also see first-time PE managers recovering in 2021 after being virtually shut out of the fundraising trail in 2020. LPs chasing outsized returns will fund new managers with pedigrees and track records. Some LPs are also receptive to new private lending funds, and a group of funds is emerging specifically to take advantage of 2021 deal flow.
Strategic M&A activity slowed to a crawl in the early summer of 2020. Low valuations didn’t necessarily translate to buy-side opportunity, since would-be targets couldn’t forecast revenue confidently and the “new normal” was continuously being reforecast. At the same time, many would-be buyers were hamstrung by their own internal problems amid the economic downturn, and spending time and cash on acquiring other companies wasn’t a possibility. Other potential buyers lacked any kind of playbook for distressed acquisitions, even if they had the capital and wherewithal to do them. However, M&A activity began to gain steam through the summer. Corporate buyers have carried some momentum forward into 2021, but a large number remain hesitant to buy in the current environment.
One trend that’s already visible is sell-side carve-out deals. Sellers are rationalizing operations and deciding to split apart businesses or products as a way of maximizing their individual valuations and focusing on core business. This is a trend we expect to continue throughout 2021, as both opportunistic competitors and PE firms alike will capitalize on this trend. One major factor is sector. Some business lines and products are less affected by COVID-19 than others. Many subsidiary companies have actually benefited from the lockdowns but aren’t a core focus of the parent company; selling those business lines through carve-outs has allowed parent companies to gain both liquidity and efficiency to support their core focus.
Family offices have been active in the PE market for years. Like Canadian pension plans, many family offices pivoted to the direct investment model as a way of reducing manager fees without sacrificing exposure. The majority of family offices, however, don’t pose direct competition to traditional PE firms. Their investments tend to reflect their mission statements and values. Their portfolio companies also tend to be family-owned businesses and are held longer by family offices, precluding a wide swath of the PE market from meeting their investment criteria. In addition, today’s family offices are navigating a generational shift in ownership. Older generations were more focused on generating yield and growing their asset bases. Newer generations are turning their firms’ attention to companies that promote good behaviours that benefit both themselves and the world. Mission statements and values are slowly redeveloping.
Did COVID-19 change anything for family offices?
We expect to see more family offices form in the years ahead, thanks to the IPO boom and more billionaires being minted. We also expect to see more deal opportunities emerge given the nature of the health care crisis, which has led to a willingness on the part of many family-owned businesses to sell to family offices specifically. A significant number of family-owned businesses don’t want to sell to traditional PE firms right now. Concerns around layoffs and the impact they would have on local communities make traditional buyouts a nonstarter. Family offices, on the other hand, represent potential buyers for families looking to hand over control after a tumultuous year.
That said, family offices are likely to be just as selective as they were pre-COVID-19. Because of their chartered mission statements and permanent capital structure, family offices tend to be more patient and less opportunistic than traditional investors. We think those tendencies will continue in 2021, despite a massive amount of disruption in family-owned businesses across multiple sectors. Because family offices operate without the constraints of LP funding, we also see potential for creativity in 2021. Family offices can offer unique equity contributions to distressed businesses, partnering with operational-focused investors who can take majority stakes in hard-hit companies.
Canadian pension plans
The value of permanent capital
Canadian pension plans have moonlighted as nontraditional PE firms for over two decades. Like family offices, Canadian pension plans have historically been active LPs in PE funds but have shifted focus to more direct and co-investments to minimize manager fees and generate further returns. For several reasons, U.S. pension plans have not transitioned to direct investments, opting instead to remain LPs only. Because of their permanent capital bases, Canadian pension plans can be selective in which deals to pursue, which can lead to uneven trends in deal activity.
Patience and creativity
As a whole, Canadian pension plans will enjoy comfortable levels of liquidity heading into 2021. The majority of plans, according to Fitch Ratings, have “sufficient cash and short-term investments to repay all outstanding debt.” With healthy liquidity and no LP agreements, Canadian pension plans can approach 2021 with a creative mindset around what types of deal structures they’d like to pursue and more. We expect these firms will have a larger appetite for co-investing, supporting more existing deals instead of sourcing them on their own. We also expect them to remain active as direct investors, since pension plans on a broader level will have more pressure in 2021 to provide returns for their members. If PE market activity resurges, Canadian pension plans will have significant opportunities to co- invest on deals they find particularly attractive.
Sovereign wealth funds
SWFs have become a reliable source of capital for PE buyouts. As LPs of the funds themselves, SWFs have negotiated their way into co-investments in certain deals. The past decade reflects how successful those negotiations have been, rising from just four co-investments in 2010 to 43 in 2019. Those minority deals have almost exclusively been upper-market deals, given the close relationships between SWFs and blue-chip firms such as Apollo and Blackstone.
Little appetite going into 2021
Coming off a record 2019, SWF co-investment activity slowed dramatically in 2020. Six of 12 months in 2020 saw only one transaction apiece that included SWF participation, according to PitchBook Data. The value generated by deals with SWF participation in 2020 was half of what it was 2019, sitting at $16.9 billion. Unlike the broader PE market, however, SWF deal activity did not see any momentum swings in the back half of the year. SWFs are selective by nature, and the drop in upper-market deal activity gave them fewer options to consider. Some of them were also hamstrung by the steep decline in energy prices, and asset allocation adjustments became a bigger priority than opportunistic co-investments. Whether deal flow picks up for them in 2021 depends on the health of the $1 billion-plus buyout market. High-end valuations recovered more quickly compared to the core middle market and lower middle market, which propelled deal volume during COVID-19. Once attractive opportunities resurface, we expect SWFs to return to pre-COVID-19 PE activity levels.