Artificial intelligence—Ready or not?

Evaluating AI readiness in private equity due diligence

October 16, 2025

Key takeaways

Use due diligence to identify prework and practical artificial intelligence use cases.

Identify industry-specific AI trends that point to being a disruptor versus being disrupted.

Incorporate findings into post-close plans to drive early EBITDA gains.

#
Business applications Due diligence Private equity

Like everyone else, operating partners are intrigued by the promise of artificial intelligence to transform businesses. But in private equity, the imperative is to prioritize practical over aspirational impact. At the same time, limited partners and boards are pressing for visible AI moves, creating urgency that can outpace readiness. For investors, this means any AI bet as a portfolio value driver must be grounded in validated use cases with a measurable line of sight to EBITDA in six months or less.

That’s no small task, especially in light of a recent report from MIT’s NANDA initiative, which shows that 95% of generative AI pilots at companies are failing. The reality is that what’s possible with AI is often grossly misaligned with what’s practical, especially for small- to mid-sized companies with very real resource constraints. Investors who are considering working AI opportunities into an investment thesis should be extra wary of the hyperbole and focus on identifying signs of real AI readiness.

Expand due diligence to check for signals of AI maturity

Yes, due diligence historically has been primarily focused on risk-based analysis. But that doesn’t mean the time can’t also be used to size up growth potential, especially where AI is concerned. Despite short windows and limited access to people and data, due diligence can give insight into indicators that AI can support the deal thesis and accelerate EBITDA. Six AI prerequisites to look for are:

AI prerequisite

Takeaway

Data: Is the company’s data collected, clean and accessible to fuel AI? According to the RSM Middle Market AI Survey 2025, data quality is the top concern for AI adopters. So, it’s important to paint a clear data picture sooner rather than later. Consider asking, “How often do you encounter missing or incorrect data in your systems?” Or, “How easy is it to combine data from different departments?”

If the answers point to data silos, a lack of data governance and/or a lack of cataloging discipline, there’s a good chance that data best practices are nonexistent or immature.

That doesn’t mean the company or future AI investments are a lost cause. It just means the value creation team will have to spend time post-close centralizing data and establishing governance before achieving any meaningful results from AI. These considerations will directly affect costs, returns and value creation timelines, so investors should be aware up front.

Technology infrastructure: Are the computing platforms, integrations and tools in place to develop and deploy AI solutions at scale? If the data checks out, the technology infrastructure and integrations are up next. Modern AI workloads and solutions typically run in the cloud and must be supported by application program interfaces. So, outdated infrastructure will throw up roadblocks, and deal teams should anticipate investing additional resources before AI can be successfully implemented.

During due diligence, aim to learn what computing resources the company currently uses for AI workloads and determine the feasibility of scaling quickly. If the infrastructure is largely based on legacy, on-premises systems, manual data pipelines or ad hoc integrations, expect to spend time and resources on integrating existing systems and building an enterprise AI environment as a priority.

Skilled talent: Does the organization have the right expertise to support AI projects? Are employees being upskilled? Regardless of how good the tech stack may be, human beings with the capabilities to design, build, adopt and manage AI are still essential. Look specifically for AI or analytics expertise and ask what specific roles the company staffs. Is AI training offered? To whom and how often?

Companies that depend heavily on external resources or that do little to upskill their own people in AI likely have considerable skills gaps that will hinder success. New operating partners may want to think about how to formalize an AI training program and decide which AI-specific skills need to be hired into the company first.

Governance and security guardrails: Are governance, security and compliance guardrails in place? The more AI comes into play, the more risk vectors are introduced, from accidentally exposing proprietary data to embedding hidden biases into models. That’s why guardrails matter. Probe into whether a target has any documented AI policies or guidelines. Do they: set boundaries on acceptable AI use? Require human review for high-stakes decisions? Define practices for data privacy and model bias?

Vagueness or inconsistency on these topics probably mean you’re looking at an AI program without a strong ethical or security foundation, which needs to be addressed as a first-wave priority after closing. Drafting and rolling out a usage policy, defining AI oversight structures, and setting security and compliance standards will help protect the organization so AI can generate value instead of inviting new challenges.

Cultural openness: Is the culture ready for AI-driven change? Even the most advanced AI models and platforms won’t deliver value if the people expected to use them are skeptical, resistant or fearful. Due diligence can be a great time to explore how employees really feel about AI. Ask questions like: “What concerns have surfaced—job security, decision accuracy or broader disruption?” Or, “How has leadership communicated AI’s purpose and benefits?” Ideally, you want to get a sense that employees are curious or at least open to integrating AI into workflows, even if full-fledged buy-in doesn’t yet exist.

If instead your queries are met with apprehension, lack of clarity or low trust, cultural resistance is likely to delay or derail AI efforts. This points to an opportunity to lean into structured change management during the early days of value creation. That might include executive storytelling that positions AI as a partner rather than a threat, training to build confidence and hands-on support to show employees how AI tools make their work easier.

Aligned use cases: Is there a clear AI strategy with AI use cases aligned with business goals? The real test of AI maturity often comes down to how thoughtfully AI initiatives connect to what the business wants to achieve.

This is where industry context matters. Some sectors, like health care or financial services, are brimming with automation opportunities that can reduce manual effort and free people for more strategic work, cutting direct costs and generating additional value. Other industries may benefit more from market-facing AI tools that drive top-line opportunities, such as identifying request-for-proposal opportunities that are most likely to result in a win.

Of course, AI use cases don’t always have to involve custom-built solutions or heavy investments. Some targets have sizable value creation opportunities simply by leveraging a tool like Microsoft Copilot. The key is to look for alignment with clear outcomes: Do leaders tie initiatives back to measurable goals, or is AI being used simply for AI’s sake? Creating a formal AI roadmap that connects the most promising initiatives to a growth strategy will be the key to accelerating returns.

AI use-case successes

RSM empowers companies across industries to develop and implement AI-driven solutions that deliver measurable EBITDA improvements.

Large hospital system automates claims appeals to drive efficiency and revenue recovery

Solution: Trained an Al model to generate letters of appeal, reducing reliance on manual processing and freeing highly trained nurses to return to patient care. The automation solution improved efficiency while increasing revenue recovery, accelerating cash flow and reducing denials.

Outcomes:

  • One-time implementation project
  • ~$2.4 million in anticipated annual savings
  • Large percentage of nursing staff reallocated from a revenue cycle task to more strategic initiatives

Engineering consulting firm wins more work with less effort

Solution: Introduced an AI-driven intelligence platform using natural language processing and machine learning to analyze request-for-proposal opportunities, match them to core capabilities and prioritize bids based on geographic and trend alignment. The system streamlined proposal processes, reducing proposal misalignment and manual effort and boosting strategic focus.

Outcomes:

  • 20%+ increase in RFP win rate
  • 60%+ reduction in RFP review time
  • 20%+ revenue boost from wins

Turn diligence into advantage

Assessing AI readiness during due diligence isn’t just about spotting risks—it’s about spotting potential and better understanding if and when AI’s prospective impact can be confidently integrated into the investment thesis. Using diligence to evaluate issues ranging from data quality to culture can help identify where AI is most likely to create value and drive early EBITDA growth, and where it may require additional investment or patience. That insight gives value creation teams a head start on shaping 100-day plans and post-close initiatives that put portfolio companies on the fast track to real improvement.

RSM contributors

  • Craig Coffaro
    IT Due Diligence Leader
  • Mike Oberschmidt
    Mike Oberschmidt
    Director

Accelerate your AI strategy with
RSM's AI Readiness Assessment

Begin with a customized AI roadmap built for results